Same Animal, Different Cages Vol. 3: Civil War Songs (for Solo Harmonica)

by David First

  • Streaming + Download

    Includes unlimited streaming via the free Bandcamp app, plus high-quality download in MP3, FLAC and more.

    Download includes PDF version of LP insert with David's liner notes.
    Purchasable with gift card

      $9 USD  or more


  • Record/Vinyl + Digital Album

    Pre-order vinyl edition for October 18, 2017 release date.

    Transparent red vinyl (150 pressed)
    Black vinyl (350 pressed)

    Includes insert and download card.

    You can also save a few dollars by subscribing to the "Same Animal, Different Cages" series here -

    By subscribing, you will receive Vols 1 to 3 and the subsequent volumes as they become available. There are only a limited number of subscription bundles available.

    Includes unlimited streaming of Same Animal, Different Cages Vol. 3: Civil War Songs (for Solo Harmonica) via the free Bandcamp app, plus high-quality download in MP3, FLAC and more.
    ships out within 3 days
    edition of 500 

      $15 USD or more 




In the third volume of the Same Animal, Different Cages series, American composer David First does a 180 from the purely sound-for-sound’s sake explorations of the first two volumes and, in their stead, gives us eleven emotional outpourings performed exclusively on solo harmonica. Despite this minimalist single-instrument approach, First manages to make each of these songs sound fully realized, anything more would simply be crowding the sonic space. 

From the high-pitched harmonics that open “Hymn for the Sick and the Poor”, the sorrowful tones of “Lamentations for the Killed”, the warm and playful “My Family of Friends”, minimalist drones of “Transition Chant”, to the hopeful swings of “The Truth Shall Reign Again Someday,” First has produced perhaps one of the first folk-music responses to the era of Trump and right-wing populism. But it’s more than that as well. The synth-like otherworldly sounds First coaxes out of his instrument on these tracks are a revelation—he has done nothing less than reinvent the harmonica.

Organic, soulful, melancholy and uplifting, "Civil War Songs" is protest music made for our times. In the face of this horrifying administration and the racist and fascist goons it has allowed out of the woodwork, First offers up a wordless experimental album that celebrates solidarity, friendship, community and principled resistance. Rather than providing an escape, these hymns wake you out of that paralyzing feeling of despair so you can find renewed focus and fight on. 

This is an asymmetrical war being fought, where the enemy are those of us who are not entirely white, not wealthy enough, not on board with the "America First" rhetoric, not quite straight, not religious enough (or of a different religion), or who don't believe that "greed is good". We need new narratives, new fight songs to inspire us. With this album, David First is giving us just that.


released October 18, 2017

All compositions by David First
2017 Silent Graph Music (ASCAP)
All tracks recorded at Higher Office Studios.
Mastered by Timothy Stollenwerk at Stereophonic Mastering
Album artwork by Joao Da Silva

Same Animal, Different Cages is made possible in part through the generous support of the New Music USA Project Grant program.


all rights reserved



Fabrica Records Brooklyn, New York

Fabrica Records is a Brooklyn, NY - based independent music label that focuses on documenting and promoting the work of experimental musicians.

To purchase physical editions, please visit -

contact / help

Contact Fabrica Records

Streaming and
Download help

Shipping and returns

Redeem code

Report this album or account

If you like Same Animal, Different Cages Vol. 3: Civil War Songs (for Solo Harmonica), you may also like: